Top-Rated Hotels in Garden City

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Zuzanna Ersoy

Updated: 30 August 2024 · 3 min

Nestled in the charming city of Garden City lies a plethora of accommodation options that promise a memorable stay. From budget-friendly boutique hotels to lavish luxury resorts, there is something to suit every traveler's preference in this quaint town. The allure of Garden City's hotels extends beyond mere lodging; each establishment offers a unique blend of comfort, convenience, and top-notch hospitality, making for an unforgettable guest experience.

As you venture through the vibrant streets of Garden City, the abundance of hotels showcases the town's unwavering commitment to providing visitors with a delightful stay. Whether you seek a cozy bed and breakfast nestled amidst lush gardens or a modern hotel with state-of-the-art amenities, Garden City's hotel offerings are as diverse as the travelers who grace its charming streets. The warm welcome and personalized service you'll receive at these hotels Garden City are sure to make you feel right at home from the moment you arrive.

For those seeking a tranquil retreat or a bustling city escape, Garden City's hotels present the ideal base for exploring all that this enchanting destination has to offer. Immerse yourself in the rich history and natural beauty of Garden City, knowing that a comfortable haven awaits you at the end of each day's adventures. With an array of accommodation options to choose from, your stay in Garden City is bound to be a harmonious blend of relaxation, exploration, and unparalleled hospitality.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 5

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Hyatt Place Garden City Hotel
2. Garden City Hotel
3. Hampton Inn By Hilton Garden City Long Island
4. Residence Inn Long Island Garden City
5. La Quinta By Wyndham Garden City Hotel

Luxury Hotels Garden City

Check Availability

Garden City
Mar 12, 2026 - Mar 13, 2026

Hyatt Place Garden City Hotel

8.3

Good

(972 Reviews)

+ 86 photos
With a reputation for contemporary design and exceptional service, Hyatt Place Garden City offers a harmonious blend of style and comfort. Guests can enjoy spacious rooms, a 24/7 gym, and a rooftop terrace with panoramic views of the city. The hotel's proximity to shopping centers and fine dining establishments ensures a delightful experience for those looking to indulge in the best that Garden City has to offer.
Address: 5 North Ave
Rating: Good 8.3 (972 Reviews)
Rooms: 122
Price: From 149$

Garden City Hotel

8.4

Good

(339 Reviews)

+ 156 photos
As a landmark destination in Garden City, the Garden City Hotel is renowned for its timeless sophistication and exceptional hospitality. The hotel's luxurious rooms are elegantly appointed with upscale amenities, and guests can indulge in gourmet dining at its award-winning restaurant. With a rich history dating back to the early 20th century, this boutique hotel perfectly encapsulates the essence of Garden City's elegance and refinement.
Address: 45 Seventh Street
Rating: Good 8.4 (339 Reviews)
Rooms: 272
Price: From 226$

Boutique Hotels Garden City

For travelers seeking a unique and intimate experience, boutique hotels in Garden City offer a charming alternative to traditional accommodations. These boutique establishments are known for their personalized service, stylish décor, and attention to detail, providing guests with a memorable stay unlike any other. Explore the hidden gems of Garden City through these boutique hotels Garden City that exude character and charm.

Hampton Inn By Hilton Garden City Long Island

8.1

Good

(541 Reviews)

+ 109 photos
Combining convenience and comfort, Hampton Inn By Hilton Garden City Long Island is a popular choice for travelers seeking a cozy retreat in the lively heart of Garden City. The hotel's well-appointed rooms, complimentary hot breakfast, and indoor pool provide a welcoming haven for guests seeking relaxation. Its warm hospitality and prime location make it a top pick for those looking to unwind in style during their visit to Garden City.
Address: 1 North Avenue
Rating: Good 8.1 (541 Reviews)
Rooms: 143
Price: From 149$

Residence Inn Long Island Garden City

9.0

Good

(224 Reviews)

+ 26 photos
Offering a blend of residential comfort and modern convenience, Residence Inn Long Island Garden City provides guests with a home away from home experience. The spacious suites feature fully equipped kitchens, separate living areas, and complimentary breakfast to ensure a comfortable stay. The hotel's central location near shopping outlets and entertainment venues makes it an ideal choice for extended stays in Garden City.
Address: 700 Garden City Plaza
Rating: Good 9.0 (224 Reviews)
Rooms: 163
Price: From 313$

La Quinta By Wyndham Garden City Hotel

7.5

Good

(1152 Reviews)

+ 50 photos
Nestled in the lively heart of Garden City boasts modern elegance and a range of upscale amenities. The hotel's well-appointed rooms feature plush bedding, high-speed internet, and a complimentary breakfast to start your day right. Its convenient location near popular attractions makes it an ideal choice for both leisure and business travelers looking to explore the charm of Garden City.
Address: 821 Stewart Avenue
Rating: Good 7.5 (1152 Reviews)
Rooms: 129
Price: From 115$